Teefury

I say no nose.

i think we need to see a pic with the nose as well in order to decide between the two,what do you say?

i'd like the two pics side by side, but i'm leaning towards nose, but again depends on how it'll look once drawn. i feel pretty confident though.

Ok I'll be uploading a pick of it with a nose tonight when I get off of work.

Oscar doesn't have a nose. Therefore, I say no nose.
Marx's nose is quite large, and does give him a certain 'look'. Therefore, maybe the nose would be better.

I was drawing it with a nose last night and there just isn't enough room for the nose on oscars face.... I looks kinda stupid with it.....

I would find a way to add the nose, but fill in the eyebrows and moustache so they stand out better and contribute to the contrast of the overall piece. If there was no room for the nose, then the rest of the face would be disproportionate and "wrong-looking".

Yes, you could go either way, because one character has no nose, and the other does have one. You probably have enough features of both of them, so it really has to be artist's choice. If you've already tried the nose, you know better than the rest of us!